Every site we tested, misses included.
We loaded 69 popular European sites in a fresh browser, once with Cookie Away, once with Consent-O-Matic and once with nothing, then checked what each site recorded. 58 of them showed a cookie banner.
| Cookie Away 4.2.4 | Consent-O-Matic 1.1.5 | |
|---|---|---|
| Banners with a free way to say no, rejected | 26 of 27 | 15 of 26 |
| Pay-or-accept walls handled without paying or accepting | 31 of 31 | 27 of 31 |
| Times it ended on a subscription or payment page | 0 | 3 |
| Times it accepted tracking | 0 | 1 |
All 69 sites.
| Site | Banner | Cookie Away | Consent-O-Matic | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ad.nl | Free to reject | Rejected | Banner stayed | |
| asos.com | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| bbc.com | Free to reject | Banner stayed | Banner stayed | Reject is on a separate settings page |
| blocket.se | Free to reject | Rejected | Banner stayed | |
| booking.com | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| dn.se | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| dr.dk | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| expressen.se | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| gp.se | Free to reject | Rejected | Banner stayed | |
| hm.com | Free to reject | Banner gone | Blocked by the site | Consent-O-Matic’s run got “Access Denied” from the site |
| idealo.de | Free to reject | Banner gone | Banner stayed | |
| ikea.com | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| independent.co.uk | Free to reject | Rejected | Banner stayed | |
| lidl.de | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| marktplaats.nl | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| nu.nl | Free to reject | Rejected | Banner stayed | |
| otto.de | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| politiken.dk | Free to reject | Banner gone | Banner stayed | |
| rtve.es | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| ryanair.com | Free to reject | Banner gone | Banner stayed | |
| spotify.com | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| svt.se | Free to reject | Banner gone | Banner stayed | |
| techradar.com | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| trustpilot.com | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| wetransfer.com | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| zalando.se | Free to reject | Banner gone | Banner stayed | |
| zara.com | Free to reject | Rejected | Rejected | |
| 20minutes.fr | Pay or accept | Left for you | Sent to a payment page | Consent-O-Matic ended on the subscription page |
| aftonbladet.se | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| allocine.fr | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| ansa.it | Pay or accept | Left for you | Sent to a payment page | Consent-O-Matic ended on the subscription page |
| as.com | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| bild.de | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| chefkoch.de | Pay or accept | Left for you | Accepted tracking | Consent-O-Matic accepted all 11 purposes |
| chip.de | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| corriere.it | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| dailymail.co.uk | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| elconfidencial.com | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| elmundo.es | Pay or accept | Left for you | Rejected | |
| elpais.com | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| faz.net | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| gazzetta.it | Pay or accept | Left for you | Sent to a payment page | Consent-O-Matic ended on the subscription page |
| heise.de | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| lefigaro.fr | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | “Continue without accepting” leads to the subscription page |
| lemonde.fr | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| leparisien.fr | Pay or accept | Left for you | Rejected | |
| marca.com | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| marmiton.org | Pay or accept | Refused, then a pay wall | Refused, then a pay wall | Refusing leads to a second “accept or subscribe” screen |
| mirror.co.uk | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| ouest-france.fr | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| repubblica.it | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| spiegel.de | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| standard.co.uk | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| svd.se | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| t-online.de | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| theguardian.com | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| vg.no | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| welt.de | Pay or accept | Left for you | Left for you | |
| nos.nl | Notice only | – | – | An information bar with no choice to make |
| bol.com | No banner | – | – | |
| ebay.de | No banner | – | – | |
| lequipe.fr | No banner | – | – | |
| reddit.com | No banner | – | – | |
| stackoverflow.com | No banner | – | – | |
| telegraaf.nl | No banner | – | – | |
| telegraph.co.uk | No banner | – | – | |
| zeit.de | No banner | – | – | |
| hemnet.se | Blocked us | – | – | The site showed our test browser a Cloudflare check |
| leboncoin.fr | Blocked us | – | – | The site showed our test browser a captcha |
Small, honest, repeatable.
Setup. Cookie Away’s column is one run of version 4.2.4 on all sites; Consent-O-Matic’s comes from the same setup earlier the same day. Headless Chromium from Sweden, a fresh profile for every site, the extension loaded unpacked, 12 seconds per page. Consent-O-Matic is the official 1.1.5 release with its default settings.
What counts as rejected. The banner is gone and the site’s consent tool (TCF, OneTrust, Cookiebot or Didomi) records no consents. “Banner gone” means it went away but the site doesn’t expose what it recorded; we checked those screenshots by hand.
Pay-or-accept walls. Some sites only let you reject if you subscribe. Leaving those for you to decide counts as handled; ending on a payment page or accepting tracking doesn’t.
The catch. These are the sites we used to find and fix Cookie Away’s bugs, so the final numbers flatter it. The fairer comparison is the first run on sites Cookie Away hadn’t seen yet: there it answered 13 of 16 banners with a free “no”, and Consent-O-Matic 9 of 15. One country, one day, and banners change all the time, so treat all of this as a snapshot.
The test scripts are in the repository under bench/. Tell us about a site and we’ll add it.